Yea a lot of reviews are fake. There are a lot more spectators than participants in this hobby. Most people write fake reviews just to maintain an active member status to see other people’s reviews. That is why there are so many short single paragraph reviews that provide absolutely no content.
I agree with you about the short single paragraph reviews. The longer a review the easier it is tell it's made up. I think the faking guys won't answer questions or do comment about a provider for fear of betraying themselves.
Although I think a few longer reviews are fake, especially first one or two glowing reviews of a new provider to help kick start her since even if good it takes a few weeks to get reviews going. However, I've been pretty reluctant to blame any monger for shilling since I can't find a pattern of suspicious behavior.
For example, the first review of Celine on ampreviews basically says she looks like her pics (can't do more detail without disclosing private info) which is in complete disagreement with my experience. (He didn't answer if her pics were accurate). But, when I search the first reviewer's past reviews and comments, he seems perfectly credible as a real monger.
Other times, I've similarly been unable to resolve this type of contradiction. Also, I've never for sure found a long fake review, short ones yes.
It did just occur to me that maybe Cara's Angeles didn't send me to Celine, but some 10 year older version. I hadn't seen anyome at Cara's since last Dec. I also didn't have any difficulty pre-booking at noon, the day before which is not what I would expect. Maybe since they didn't think me a regular what was the harm. I also got kind of a snarky response from the PO, over the 11 month since last appointment. Although the woman's face I was sent to did trigger recognition of Celine in pics, although different, but it could be a fake recognition.
The other explanation is that Celine's service is so good that guys don't actually remember what she looks like and have to use her pics as reference. John6615 pointed out that if you have a good experience, in the warm glow you aren't very objective or critical, everything is good, rather the negative experience makes you more objective. (As to why...)
After a good experience first time, I can't remember a lot of physical details, like how much fat on stomach. I only notice things that push my buttons, like too much stomach fat, it ripples when bending over, or she's sniffling. I only notice things like what her butt is like if I consciously remind myself to look at her butt, what shape, how much stomach fat, what it looks like when she bends over. I usually remember what her boobs are like because they are important.
I also think that if guys have a really good service experience, the provider becomes more beautiful, and that they don't need to be accurate in description, they don't want to say anything negative, but will actually make up positive stuff about her, since no one will challenge them on the their experience.
Guys don't like to write negative reviews about a provider because they might get challenged like I did, but also since they don't want to dwell on a bad experience.
I'm repeating.