AMP Reviews
  • You asked and we delivered! AMPReviews now provides the option to upgrade to VIP access via paid subscription as an alternative to writing your own reviews. VIP Access allows you to read all the hidden content within member-submitted reviews AND gives access to private VIP-only forums in each city. You can upgrade your account INSTANTLY by visiting the Account Upgrades page in your own user profile and using a valid credit card to purchase a subscription. You can get to this page by clicking the link in any review, by clicking the red "See the Details Now" banner on the home page, and by clicking the Purchase Private Details link in the navbar at the top of every page

Review: Bulk Review at AD: Cindy, Michelle, Sammi

YoungLooking24

Review Contributor
Messages: 4,401
Reviews: 30
Joined
#21
I can now add Bibi to this compilation of superlatives. She doesnt displace anyone in the above categories, but gets wins in some new categories.

Bibi: oldest in appearance (lets say early 40s, passing for late 30s), most obvious signs of childbirth. BUT most hourglassy figure, and probably a hair ahead of Cindy for best head to toe appearance. Depends on how old you are and your feelings about (younger side of) milfy faces. Like Cindy, a pleasant but not quite pretty face. I'd call Bibi's a more coventional pleasant face, so while I'd rate them about equally, Cindy has a more unique look and more likely to elicit a wider range of opinions.

While Bibi's ass isn't what you see her for, probably the best view in doggie of these 4. Top is both a touch smaller than I had hoped for (but solid Cs) and softer than I had feared. Pretty decent job. So, 3 out of 4 here have really top notch tops.

Sweet personality. Bad English. Service comparable to the others (so, quite good!), though the bbj, while fine, probs ranks 4th out of 4. Touch toothy. They're all kind of screamers, but hers were sort of quiet (dare I say elegant?), more plausible screams compared to Bibi and Michelle.

Overall, I'd still call Cindy my fav of the bunch, due to our chemistry, but Bibi's another solid option here. And, yeah, still glad I had the variety of a 4th girl vs repeating with Cindy.

Btw, saw Sammi on the way out in her towel. I feel a little bad calling her fat before. She's a cutie and a sweetie. A soft round cutie but a cutie. For me personally, the biggest knock on Sammi's look isnt really her belly, it's the weird divot I mentioned in the review.

Next, Stacy. (At least at this place).
Cant wait to see your review on stacy. Even though there's nothing more you can add that we all dont know already lol.

I'll just assume you're the next fan of hers. Have fun with her dude!
 

BrettKavanaugh

Review Contributor
Messages: 1,609
Reviews: 95
Joined
#22
Well, I mentioned I HAVE laid eyes (and a bit of hands) on Stacy, and other than seeing her completely au naturel, I feel like I have a good sense how that will go down. She's the prettiest of the bunch, and most petite. And LOOKS surprisingly young and fresh. Cant fully assess her bum, top seemed smaller than the others (small side of Cs) but still proportional, and while encased in whatever she was wearing looked and felt soft enough. Feel confident the service will show she's dedicated to her craft. It'll be a question of chemistry - if she can pull off any semblance of a non-professional feeling, and, how well her surgeon's work will pass a more thorough inspection. With unlimited funds, I think I'd go straight to a Cindy-Stacy double, as Stacy did describe to me what she would do to Cindy. Very compelling marketing strategy, I must say.
 

YoungLooking24

Review Contributor
Messages: 4,401
Reviews: 30
Joined
#23
Well, I mentioned I HAVE laid eyes (and a bit of hands) on Stacy, and other than seeing her completely au naturel, I feel like I have a good sense how that will go down. She's the prettiest of the bunch, and most petite. And LOOKS surprisingly young and fresh. Cant fully assess her bum, top seemed smaller than the others (small side of Cs) but still proportional, and while encased in whatever she was wearing looked and felt soft enough. Feel confident the service will show she's dedicated to her craft. It'll be a question of chemistry - if she can pull off any semblance of a non-professional feeling, and, how well her surgeon's work will pass a more thorough inspection. With unlimited funds, I think I'd go straight to a Cindy-Stacy double, as Stacy did describe to me what she would do to Cindy. Very compelling marketing strategy, I must say.
If you're a fan of Lucia, you'll love stacy. Same style, same sex drive, doesnt quit until you tap out.

And imho, a better body than Lucia.
 

BrettKavanaugh

Review Contributor
Messages: 1,609
Reviews: 95
Joined
#25
If you're a fan of Lucia, you'll love stacy. Same style, same sex drive, doesnt quit until you tap out.

And imho, a better body than Lucia.
Obviously can't speak about a session with Stacy, but they have very different vibes physically, so body-wise it's probably apples and oranges. Lucia oozes pure sex more than anyone I've seen. Stacy can pull off a sweet and innocent look. But I can see what you mean given their demeanor. I also first met Lucia after a session with someone else, and she gave me a look that my brain interpreted not as a suggestion, but as a COMMAND to return asap to **** her. Another one with good marketing skills.

(Btw, I say this as someone who had a pretty great time with Lucia, but who enjoyed 5-7 other PH girls, past and present, even more).
 

YoungLooking24

Review Contributor
Messages: 4,401
Reviews: 30
Joined
#26
Obviously can't speak about a session with Stacy, but they have very different vibes physically, so body-wise it's probably apples and oranges. Lucia oozes pure sex more than anyone I've seen. Stacy can pull off a sweet and innocent look. But I can see what you mean given their demeanor. I also first met Lucia after a session with someone else, and she gave me a look that my brain interpreted not as a suggestion, but as a COMMAND to return asap to **** her. Another one with good marketing skills.

(Btw, I say this as someone who had a pretty great time with Lucia, but who enjoyed 5-7 other PH girls, past and present, even more).
I saw the same vibe with stacy. Although it might be slightly different with stacy because of certain things i can't and won't explain in threads but i definitely got the same vibe with both of those girls. I am sure others who have seen both can concede to that. Lucia definitely exudes pure sex and if you're looking for innocent GFE, she's not the one. She can play the role but she's not the girl for that. You see lucia for PSE. I see stacy as a more versatile provider. She can play all roles. That's the difference between a novice hungry girl (lucia) trying to climb the ranks vs a girl, a vet (stacy), who has been in the game for so long, she knows what role to play.

I have enjoyed all the girls i saw at PH, i seen them all during their hay day. I have seen lucia a ton of times. But only about 5-6 times at PH. She's fucking incredible. I just met stacy, and i put her in the same category as lucia.

And i plan to see stacy more and more.

Funny how a thread of THREE girls from AD, not including stacy, yet we're talking about stacy. Someone give that girl a medal lol
 

BrettKavanaugh

Review Contributor
Messages: 1,609
Reviews: 95
Joined
#29
Since comparisons to PH providers have come up (natural given the location), I'd like to clarify something. I like this place so far, and have greatly enjoyed all 4 girls Ive seen. Still, they've been a notch below those top 5-7 PH girls I hinted at above. Joey and Rachel are at a higher plane in my mind, as well as some past PH stars and guest stars. These AD girls so far are more at the level of the next rung at PH, like Vivian, Nikko, Ivyna, and maybe not even quite that level. All great girls to be sure, but not life altering.

Nevertheless I am having a blast working my way through this roster. Part of the fun is bumping into the other girls you've already seen. Feels a bit like having a harem.
 

YoungLooking24

Review Contributor
Messages: 4,401
Reviews: 30
Joined
#30
You're also comparing girls who are already a staple to the NYC GFE traditional vs girls who are still finding their way. Stacy is the only one at AD whom everyone here would attest to, that she has those skills, those abilities and that experience to be classified among the elite. I mean she did work with, learn and is friends with the famous kathy for crying out loud. I think her girls will eventually get to that level soon.

I can't make any judgement on the other AD girls so i can't comment on that so perhaps your analysis is correct. But i say give it time and AD will be right up there with the almighty PH.

In life, it's always good to have options.
 

BrettKavanaugh

Review Contributor
Messages: 1,609
Reviews: 95
Joined
#31
Gonna have to respectfully disagree. Those top PH girls fully check off the 4 main boxes. Face, body, carnal skills, friendly demeanor. These AD girls check off 2.5 to 3.5 of those boxes. But where they trail is not in service/demeanor. They already have that. In fact, Id say where this place deserves the hype is that I'm now 4 for 4 in terms of great service/skills/attitude. That's pretty damn good consistency and rivals PH. It's the face and/or body. Cindy is great, loved her, want her to do well in life, but she's not gonna get prettier with experience. I suppose Bibi has that potential if she drops 15-20 pounds and cleans up the boob situation.

Again, not a knock on these girls. They're all better than I deserve! If you're like me and prize variety (within the realm of Chinese girls) this is a great team.
 

YoungLooking24

Review Contributor
Messages: 4,401
Reviews: 30
Joined
#33
You're preaching to the choir my good man lol. I already said the other AD girls will get to that level soon. The PH girls you're comparing to are considered vets in the game. I tried girl after girl in the past. The ones that couldn't sustain high levels of service either got kicked out or moved to a different spot.

Of all the people who post here, you're 1 of the 3, or maybe 4 i value the most. WG being the strong other. You 2 definitely know your shit so i respect your assessment. I can't comment on the other AD girls because i haven't seen them.

And please see stacy already so you can make it 5 for 5.
 

night5678

Monger Kong
Messages: 716
Reviews: 55
Joined
#34
Your honor, I am but a simpleton so I must ask; between Michelle and Bibi who has the better tits? I'm always on the hunt for an amazing Russian so size and shape is important. Though I also have to worry about them being able to completely wrap around jr completely.
 

BrettKavanaugh

Review Contributor
Messages: 1,609
Reviews: 95
Joined
#35
Your honor, I am but a simpleton so I must ask; between Michelle and Bibi who has the better tits? I'm always on the hunt for an amazing Russian so size and shape is important. Though I also have to worry about them being able to completely wrap around jr completely.
The answer is already embedded above. But Ill save you time. If we're just talking tits, Michelle by a mile.
 

BrettKavanaugh

Review Contributor
Messages: 1,609
Reviews: 95
Joined
#36
The answer is already embedded above. But Ill save you time. If we're just talking tits, Michelle by a mile.
You know what? For some reason I keep mixing up which one is Bibi and which one is Sammi. So let me revise that answer. Still Michelle, comfortably, but not by a mile. Bibi's top is pretty nice too. And Bibi trumps Michelle in every other appearance-related category except age.
 

night5678

Monger Kong
Messages: 716
Reviews: 55
Joined
#37
You know what? For some reason I keep mixing up which one is Bibi and which one is Sammi. So let me revise that answer. Still Michelle, comfortably, but not by a mile. Bibi's top is pretty nice too. And Bibi trumps Michelle in every other appearance-related category except age.
Thanks a bunch for the clarification BK. I'll keep that in mind for my next outing. Cheers.
 

BrettKavanaugh

Review Contributor
Messages: 1,609
Reviews: 95
Joined
#38
Thanks a bunch for the clarification BK. I'll keep that in mind for my next outing. Cheers.
You do this often enough, and seems like you're a boob guy....see them both! They'll both show up on my next expanded version of greatest boobs list. (Once I hit 50 worthy pairs). Cindy will make the cut too. I will say Bibi's nice tits are kind of conventionally nice, mostly well-done (but not fooling anyone) c+ implants on a girl with a waist, so she looks good. But if you're craving unique memorable experiences, she doesn't quite fit that bill. Michelle's rack has a unique roundness (without looking like volleyballs) that I found compelling. Unfortunately, the rest of her appearance was on the meh side. Cindy has her own boob thing going on too, depending on how you feel about "longer" saggier sets. (I personally feel the sag is still within the bounds of reason, and her natural softness was a nice change of pace from the usual implanted girls...not that I dont love me my implanted girls. Obviously.)

Sammi won't make the list. But Sammi will make the (very short) list of top fat Asian providers with just ok tops who still somehow exude sexiness due to cute/pretty faces, nice lips, smooth young skin, and well-simulated nympho demeanor.
 

night5678

Monger Kong
Messages: 716
Reviews: 55
Joined
#39
You do this often enough, and seems like you're a boob guy....see them both! They'll both show up on my next expanded version of greatest boobs list. (Once I hit 50 worthy pairs). Cindy will make the cut too. I will say Bibi's nice tits are kind of conventionally nice, mostly well-done (but not fooling anyone) c+ implants on a girl with a waist, so she looks good. But if you're craving unique memorable experiences, she doesn't quite fit that bill. Michelle's rack has a unique roundness (without looking like volleyballs) that I found compelling. Unfortunately, the rest of her appearance was on the meh side. Cindy has her own boob thing going on too, depending on how you feel about "longer" saggier sets. (I personally feel the sag is still within the bounds of reason, and her natural softness was a nice change of pace from the usual implanted girls...not that I dont love me my implanted girls. Obviously.)

Sammi won't make the list. But Sammi will make the (very short) list of top fat Asian providers with just ok tops who still somehow exude sexiness due to cute/pretty faces, nice lips, smooth young skin, and well-simulated nympho demeanor.
I could see them both, but I'm trying to be "financially responsible" for the time being so I must be much more diligent with research. Your boob compendium came in real handy while I was making decisions the last few months so I figured I'd ask for a more personal response; once again, thank you for your input.
 

BrettKavanaugh

Review Contributor
Messages: 1,609
Reviews: 95
Joined
#40
I could see them both, but I'm trying to be "financially responsible" for the time being so I must be much more diligent with research. Your boob compendium came in real handy while I was making decisions the last few months so I figured I'd ask for a more personal response; once again, thank you for your input.
I'm probably a little TOO happy to compare and contrast all the wonderful asian hooters we have at our disposal, so any time! As a reminder, #'s 1, 5, 6, 9, 12, 13, 19, 22, 24, 31 and 38 all also appear to be generally available these days. Looks like you've reviewed 6 and 19 so far. I'll probably slot Michelle a bit ahead of Vicky who is currently at 19, but behind the others. To be sure, there are certainly critiques to be made of those others in their non-boob components. Except for #1. No critiques allowed of #1.

Hey, you've seen Lumi, aka Bess. Havent had the pleasure myself yet. How would you rank hers?
 
Top