What's the best place to get a steak in New York?

[Retired031424]

Who makes the best steak in NYC. I have few opinions myself. . . personally I think the best steaks aren't made at steakhouses. I like Craft's rib eye a lot. But I haven't been to Keen's in years. Strip House I've heard has gone downhill but when it first opened, holy shit. M. Wells in Long Island City is doing all sorts of bonkers stuff. Roberta's in Brooklyn occasionally drops the bomb with some crazy many day dry aged beef. Yes to Peter Luger but I'm not so interested in Old Homestead. There's just so much cow and so little time. Thoughts?

 

[chaoschaos]

Ikinari is great. causal and inexpensive. Keen and most steak houses are overall rated!!
https://www.ikinaristeakusa.com/

 

[Uniquelyme]

https://www.opentable.com/r/meet-the-meat-astoria

One of the best steakhouses at medium price. Many steakhouses are overrated.

 

[chaoschaos]

Ikinari is great. causal and inexpensive. Keen and most steak houses are overall rated!!
https://www.ikinaristeakusa.com/

overrated....not "overall rated"

 

[Chiparlor]

Hell’s Kitchen

 

[Ahlungor]

Not Luger’s that’s for sure...

Delmonico’s or Quality Italian perhaps? I like Strip House, but have only been once and enjoyed the bone in rib eye! Wolfgang’s I enjoyed and didn’t find it pretentious...

Keens I think is also better than Peter Lugers, and it filled with a lot of history. The original AMPReviews or Spahunters... with Mr. J P Morgan or Teddy Roosevelt themselves gracing those halls!

 

[Bolo1]

I love Keen’s for the ultimate man vibe. Delmonicos is a classic. Ikinari sucks. Lugars...overrated. Always wanted to go to Old Homestead, as I heard it’s really good too. Maybe I’ll take a break from hobbling and get something good to eat

 

[OlderGuy77]

Sparks. Tell them John sent you

 

[JohnNash]

Smith & Wollensky , by far ...
Tell 'em John Nash sent you.

 

[Jacbkk]

Del Frisco Steakhouse

 

[Bolo1]

Del Frisco Steakhouse

Good one~~forgot about them.

 

[inverse19]

Smith & Wollensky , by far ...
Tell 'em John Nash sent you.

Smith and Wollensky's prime rib is top tier, can vouch

 

[Nicksuperlover]

Del Frisco Steakhouse

Yes. Del Friscos and flash dancers after.

 

[chaoschaos]

Yes. Del Friscos and flash dancers after.

NYC high end strip clubs are such ripoffs…..I never go again...….cover charge (good seats need to buy a bottle....regular will sit in the back) + coat check + min drink + 2 lap dances >>>> that is already half a FS AMP.

 

[Nicksuperlover]

NYC high end strip clubs are such ripoffs…..I never go again...….cover charge (good seats need to buy a bottle....regular will sit in the back) + coat check + min drink + 2 lap dances >>>> that is already half a FS AMP.

Agree but I was assuming you have a fat expense account like me.

 

[Monkeyblue]

There's a place in greenpoint Brooklyn that serves an excellent steak. I think it was called amber steak or something like that. I've gone a few times and it's always been excellent.

 

[chaoschaos]

Agree but I was assuming you have a fat expense account like me.

dude, I need to PM you. Whatever you are selling , I will pretend to listen and show interest. I will create a fake linkedin profile for you industry.
and we can discuss our million deal in Hustler's club...….hahhahahahhahahahha

 

[Uniquelyme]

Agree but I was assuming you have a fat expense account like me.

 

[Retired031424]

For a time many people (not just perverts and mongers) thought that the best steakhouse in the city was Robert's in the Hustler Club. I never went there which was probs a mistake.

 

[Retired031424]

https://www.nytimes.com/2007/02/28/dining/reviews/28rest.html