While my last visit at NYAF was NOT a good visit, I'd still put them over DDY/CCP/ShangriLA or whatever name they're using. They both have their strengths and weaknesses. NYAF is usually pretty good but it depends on who is managing, if Maggie is at the helm, well good luck, she's screwed up my appointments 3x. DDY/CCP/ShangriLA has a history of bait and switch and while I've never had that issue, most of my visits of been meh at best all the way down to straight bad. The only good girls I ever saw are girls who later went to other places, two of those girls actually went to NYAF. DDY I would say has the better selection but can be hard to get to who you actually want to see because of the rampant b&s. That's just my take.