What neighborhood is this?
And how's the weather?
I heartily endorse the way you've defined your terms here. This is your thread so your ratings are your ratings and not unreasonable.
Of course, that's not going to stop me from using that framework to quibble a bit.
Let's stipulate that you're walking somewhere within the Fertile Crescent, from roughly KoreaTown, through Flatiron, Meatpacking, Village, Nolita, Alphabet City, Lower East Side, and it's a warm June Friday night. And it's not raining. I think I'm seeing about 10 girls that are a grade above Apple. And another 10-15 that are at her level. So that makes her a 7. And as you are clearly aware, none of those ten better girls can be had for 400. Well, maybe two of them can be had for 400, but none of them can be had for 400 after a single simple text. It's going to take some time and work to get in a position to even make that offer of 400, and meanwhile you're getting slapped, spat upon, or kicked in the balls by seven of the others. (Maybe that last one is on the fence, but she's holding out for a cool thousand).
So while you've been walking around those 30 minutes and dodging bodily harm, I've been enjoying some very sweet foreplay and am already 5 minutes in to the (very extended) full show with a really cute girl.
Now if it's lunchtime around Penn Station, Apple might be a 9.
I will say, yeah, IMHO hers is not an immediate jaw-dropping OMG stunner beauty. It's a little more subtle: initially cute to very cute, but over the course of the session you start to think, she is just straight up very very pretty. (Or maybe that's just me and my pheromones). A bit like VIP Momo in that way, though a different type from Momo. Agreed, not the absolute prettiest ever, even in the AMP world. But might crack my top 10 faces. Her body isn't vavavoom, and I think her lingerie choice made her seem even flatter than she really is. To the point I momentarily considered calling an audible and swapping out for Eunice, who does indeed have some luscious looking natural DDs. But I stuck to the plan and am glad I did. Turns out she has shape and tone and isn't exactly a stick.
While I get the recommendation as a good first girl for brand new monger, I would hesitate. She's TOO sweet. The boy might get confused and fall in love. Can't have that happening with his first girl. Instead, I think he needs someone a little older, who knows some things that the sweet girlfriend he just broke up with didn't know.