Keep it civil, gentlemen.
And as a general rule, you catch more flies with honey than vinegar.
@honynic07 - not sure if there's a similar Brit saying but it's pretty self-explanatory. In other words, please practice decorum, politeness, and respect to your fellow members, and they will reciprocate...and that applies to ALL members.
Perhaps a better way to ask the OP for his generally well-written review would be...hey, thanks for the review! But question...was the benji your tip or all-in? And if the former, what was the house fee? Or just send him a PM and asking him politely.
And the OP could have answered publicly, or send or reply to a PM from other members in the thread.
Also, personally (solely from the perspective as a member and veteran hobbyist myself first and foremost), I believe that guys who say or ask "PM me" when THEY'RE the one requesting info are being lazy or expecting to be spoon fed. Don't do this...the onus is on the one who is requesting the info, and I'm sure almost any member will respond, provided the question or request is asked nicely/politely.
Also, a member's own review is just that...their own. Everyone has different writing styles and methods and formats. If a particularly review isn't for you, just move on...there's plenty of other content to digest. No need to inject any negativity...that's not what we're about. We don't have to befriend every single member on the site, but do your best to treat everyone with respect. Good day indoors.