AMP Reviews
  • You asked and we delivered! AMPReviews now provides the option to upgrade to VIP access via paid subscription as an alternative to writing your own reviews. VIP Access allows you to read all the hidden content within member-submitted reviews AND gives access to private VIP-only forums in each city. You can upgrade your account INSTANTLY by visiting the Account Upgrades page in your own user profile and using a valid credit card to purchase a subscription. You can get to this page by clicking the link in any review, by clicking the red "See the Details Now" banner on the home page, and by clicking the Purchase Private Details link in the navbar at the top of every page

Review: NYAF Taylor. Never again.

mumbles17

Review Contributor
Messages: 242
Reviews: 5
Joined
#42
What am I missing? Why didn’t you simply refuse her and ask who else was available? Sort of like cold food….send it back, rather than eating it and complaining forever…..
 

JuicyApp

Review Contributor
Messages: 96
Reviews: 8
Joined
#46
I requested an appointment with Taylor @ NYAF like 2 weeks ago after seeing reviews that she gives sloppy BBBJs. It was my first time there and MMS said she was available over phone. Once I got there it was a different Asian girl I forgot the name to. She wasn't bad looking so I continued the service. It was just decent, but nothing spectacular which is obviously what I always go for. Staying away from NYAF after that.
Much better success at DDY, SL, Flushing area for me.
 

Rover2020

Review Contributor
Messages: 77
Reviews: 4
Joined
#48
@ OP
I’m sorry to hear about your experience and thank you for the heads up.

Did she look like an Oompa Loompa? If so, then I don’t know how she’s able to work there.
I'm surprised by all these negative reactions to Taylor. I just saw her last week for the first time. I read as many reviews as possible before making an appointment and her performance exceeded my expectations. She had my dick in her mouth for the first 50 minutes of our hour together then licked the cum off my dick and balls like she was cleaning melted ice cream from a sugar cone on a hot summer day.

Taylor is not the cutest girl in their lineup (I think Carry and Azu are the hottest I've seen and they're also the only ones I've had multiple repeats with) but Taylor's certainly not fugly either, just plain looking. I'd rate her about a 6 out of 10, just average looking, but everyone has their own taste and preferences. Every review of her that I've read also mentioned that's she's thick. I don't think she's chubby, unless you're expecting a spinner, which she definitely isn't. She got large natural breasts, which I greatly prefer to man made ones, and she uses them well too.

I don't usually make appointments sight unseen and prefer to look at a lineup first. I made an exception this time because I knew I was looking for an extended sloppy BBBJ. By way of background, I'm an older man and it takes me forever to finish. I rarely cum from a BJ alone, typically because the provider gets tired and asks if we can fuck instead.

There was no quit in Taylor. She can DT like a champ and kept going until she got the nut. I left very satisfied and happy with her service.

While I usually ask for a lineup at NYAF because they always have so many women available, on the occasions when I've made an appointment for a specific provider I've never had any issues. They're one of my "go to" places because of their consistency and customer service. Maybe I've just been lucky so far, but I've never had a poor experience with them.
 

B00M

Registered Member
Messages: 345
Reviews: 3
Joined
#49
I'm surprised by all these negative reactions to Taylor. I just saw her last week for the first time. I read as many reviews as possible before making an appointment and her performance exceeded my expectations. She had my dick in her mouth for the first 50 minutes of our hour together then licked the cum off my dick and balls like she was cleaning melted ice cream from a sugar cone on a hot summer day.

Taylor is not the cutest girl in their lineup (I think Carry and Azu are the hottest I've seen and they're also the only ones I've had multiple repeats with) but Taylor's certainly not fugly either, just plain looking. I'd rate her about a 6 out of 10, just average looking, but everyone has their own taste and preferences. Every review of her that I've read also mentioned that's she's thick. I don't think she's chubby, unless you're expecting a spinner, which she definitely isn't. She got large natural breasts, which I greatly prefer to man made ones, and she uses them well too.

I don't usually make appointments sight unseen and prefer to look at a lineup first. I made an exception this time because I knew I was looking for an extended sloppy BBBJ. By way of background, I'm an older man and it takes me forever to finish. I rarely cum from a BJ alone, typically because the provider gets tired and asks if we can fuck instead.

There was no quit in Taylor. She can DT like a champ and kept going until she got the nut. I left very satisfied and happy with her service.

While I usually ask for a lineup at NYAF because they always have so many women available, on the occasions when I've made an appointment for a specific provider I've never had any issues. They're one of my "go to" places because of their consistency and customer service. Maybe I've just been lucky so far, but I've never had a poor experience with them.
The thing is, if she is at least thick, the pictures should reflect that way. And it doesn't seem like it is any close to the pictures that are shown.
 

AMPhibian

Review Contributor
Messages: 188
Reviews: 23
Joined
#51
Title: Review: NYAF Taylor. Never again.
Date: Nov 10, 2023
Phone: (929) 992-8866
City: NYC
State: NY
Location: Bryant Park
House Fee & Tip (if applicable) 320
Nationality: Chinese
Age Estimate: 47
Physical Description: Ugly face, truly. Out of shape mom body. Unkempt hair. Drawn eyebrows. Large barrel belly. 1/10

Recommendation: No
Why didn’t you leave?
Some rave about a certain skill she has. Can you at least verify that’s as good as they say?
She don’t look skinny in her pic.
 

Mongeram

Review Contributor
Messages: 583
Reviews: 22
Joined
#52
I'm surprised by all these negative reactions to Taylor. I just saw her last week for the first time. I read as many reviews as possible before making an appointment and her performance exceeded my expectations. She had my dick in her mouth for the first 50 minutes of our hour together then licked the cum off my dick and balls like she was cleaning melted ice cream from a sugar cone on a hot summer day.

Taylor is not the cutest girl in their lineup (I think Carry and Azu are the hottest I've seen and they're also the only ones I've had multiple repeats with) but Taylor's certainly not fugly either, just plain looking. I'd rate her about a 6 out of 10, just average looking, but everyone has their own taste and preferences. Every review of her that I've read also mentioned that's she's thick. I don't think she's chubby, unless you're expecting a spinner, which she definitely isn't. She got large natural breasts, which I greatly prefer to man made ones, and she uses them well too.

I don't usually make appointments sight unseen and prefer to look at a lineup first. I made an exception this time because I knew I was looking for an extended sloppy BBBJ. By way of background, I'm an older man and it takes me forever to finish. I rarely cum from a BJ alone, typically because the provider gets tired and asks if we can fuck instead.

There was no quit in Taylor. She can DT like a champ and kept going until she got the nut. I left very satisfied and happy with her service.

While I usually ask for a lineup at NYAF because they always have so many women available, on the occasions when I've made an appointment for a specific provider I've never had any issues. They're one of my "go to" places because of their consistency and customer service. Maybe I've just been lucky so far, but I've never had a poor experience with them.
We have different standards, and being a cum goblin doesn’t mean the experience is good. It takes more than that
 

이 회장님

Review Contributor
Messages: 5,125
Reviews: 110
Joined
#53
I'm surprised by all these negative reactions to Taylor. I just saw her last week for the first time. I read as many reviews as possible before making an appointment and her performance exceeded my expectations. She had my dick in her mouth for the first 50 minutes of our hour together then licked the cum off my dick and balls like she was cleaning melted ice cream from a sugar cone on a hot summer day.

Taylor is not the cutest girl in their lineup (I think Carry and Azu are the hottest I've seen and they're also the only ones I've had multiple repeats with) but Taylor's certainly not fugly either, just plain looking. I'd rate her about a 6 out of 10, just average looking, but everyone has their own taste and preferences. Every review of her that I've read also mentioned that's she's thick. I don't think she's chubby, unless you're expecting a spinner, which she definitely isn't. She got large natural breasts, which I greatly prefer to man made ones, and she uses them well too.

I don't usually make appointments sight unseen and prefer to look at a lineup first. I made an exception this time because I knew I was looking for an extended sloppy BBBJ. By way of background, I'm an older man and it takes me forever to finish. I rarely cum from a BJ alone, typically because the provider gets tired and asks if we can fuck instead.

There was no quit in Taylor. She can DT like a champ and kept going until she got the nut. I left very satisfied and happy with her service.

While I usually ask for a lineup at NYAF because they always have so many women available, on the occasions when I've made an appointment for a specific provider I've never had any issues. They're one of my "go to" places because of their consistency and customer service. Maybe I've just been lucky so far, but I've never had a poor experience with them.
No need for you to be surprised because we are all entitled to our opinion. Glad you had a nice time with her.
 

hankscorpio1

Review Contributor
Messages: 117
Reviews: 23
Joined
#54
As I stated in my review of Taylor, I wasn't much impressed by her looks either. I was hoping for something more akin to what I'm used to at SpicyGirls. That said, I knew how positive the reviews were of her oral performance. So, if she can get such great reviews for her service IN SPITE of her looks, then that performance must be something special. She didn't disappoint in the service dept. In fact, I'm super-glad I went to see her (even though I was disappointed with the looks). Very few women are the true unicorns of both looks and performance. They exist, but get overbooked and jaded, or smarten up, go indy and raise prices. Just market dynamics. That old adage applies here. It's the homely ones that need to bring something else to the table to make it in the business. Massive jugs can make up for busted teeth, cute feet for no ass, throat goat for barrel-shaped gut (Taylor), stunning hot looks for loose pussy, etc. It all depends on your proclivities and what matters to you.

Personally, I always prefer service over looks. Some guys would prefer to bang a dead fish 10 than a 5 that's a tiger in the sack, or pony up $1k for the 10 in looks AND service. Just a personal preference. Nothing wrong with either as long as you have accurate expectations going in. Hopefully these reviews give honest observations so we can anticipate what we're getting with our hard-earned dollars.
 

Cum Tzu

Review Contributor
Messages: 201
Joined
#55
As I stated in my review of Taylor, I wasn't much impressed by her looks either. I was hoping for something more akin to what I'm used to at SpicyGirls. That said, I knew how positive the reviews were of her oral performance. So, if she can get such great reviews for her service IN SPITE of her looks, then that performance must be something special. She didn't disappoint in the service dept. In fact, I'm super-glad I went to see her (even though I was disappointed with the looks). Very few women are the true unicorns of both looks and performance. They exist, but get overbooked and jaded, or smarten up, go indy and raise prices. Just market dynamics. That old adage applies here. It's the homely ones that need to bring something else to the table to make it in the business. Massive jugs can make up for busted teeth, cute feet for no ass, throat goat for barrel-shaped gut (Taylor), stunning hot looks for loose pussy, etc. It all depends on your proclivities and what matters to you.

Personally, I always prefer service over looks. Some guys would prefer to bang a dead fish 10 than a 5 that's a tiger in the sack, or pony up $1k for the 10 in looks AND service. Just a personal preference. Nothing wrong with either as long as you have accurate expectations going in. Hopefully these reviews give honest observations so we can anticipate what we're getting with our hard-earned dollars.
Would you prefer 1 10 or 5 2’s?
 

hankscorpio1

Review Contributor
Messages: 117
Reviews: 23
Joined
#56
Would you prefer 1 10 or 5 2’s?
For my own standards, a woman has got to be at least 5 in looks, but then offers a 9-10 in some kind of special service. How about this for an algorithm:

Sum total of Looks + Service = 15+ with no individual score below 5

Taylor is 5 Looks + 10 service = 15
Yaya is 7 Looks + 9 Service = 16
Barbie is 8 Looks + 8 Service = 16

Understood that both Looks and Service are subjective. Unfortunately, we've probably all had too many <15 totals. I've had knockouts that were horrible, and even worse, some fuglies that didn't deliver in service either (worst case scenario). For the OP, if Taylor was subjectively a 2 in Looks, then there's no amount of Service that can get him to 15+, and he should've just asked for his money back and walked at that point.

TBH, I can't remember the last time I had a 18+. I'm not a high roller, so I don't dabble in that $400+ range where the 18-20 score can be possible. I miss the old days where the KMPs were the standard, and you could easily get a 8+ Looks with 8+ Service for $200. But, BBBJ and other GFE Service was pretty rare. These days, with the cost considerations, I have to be choosy where I find the value, probably playing in the 14 - 17 range with some missteps drifting into the 12-13 range.

Edit: I think the last 19 score I had might've been Nina from Thai Silk. Legitimate 9 Looks, 10 Service for $240. Miss her.
The last 18 I had was probably Abby at New Rainbow. 9 Looks, 9 Service.

Hank.
 

cher_cheri

Je ne regrette rien
Messages: 2,020
Reviews: 84
Joined
#57
Yeah, my scale isn't linear. If personality/attitude/skills is not good, nothing makes that up for me. Doesn't matter how hot. But if those are good, I can forgive a lot in terms of appearance. I wrote a review for Jenny @ 10Ten. Jenny is smoking. But I didn't have a good time and left feeling unsatisfied. What I didn't put in the review was what happened after. I went to console myself with Korean Fried Chicken and a Sapporo. Then decided I needed more consolation. So I went to see Taylor - Zoey not available. And I left Taylor entirely satisfied. I would never, ever have picked Taylor from a lineup, but now she fills a specific niche in my personal ecosystem of perversion.
 

rigandine

Review Contributor
Messages: 1,237
Reviews: 33
Joined
#58
For my own standards, a woman has got to be at least 5 in looks, but then offers a 9-10 in some kind of special service. How about this for an algorithm:

Sum total of Looks + Service = 15+ with no individual score below 5

Taylor is 5 Looks + 10 service = 15
Yaya is 7 Looks + 9 Service = 16
Barbie is 8 Looks + 8 Service = 16

Understood that both Looks and Service are subjective. Unfortunately, we've probably all had too many <15 totals. I've had knockouts that were horrible, and even worse, some fuglies that didn't deliver in service either (worst case scenario). For the OP, if Taylor was subjectively a 2 in Looks, then there's no amount of Service that can get him to 15+, and he should've just asked for his money back and walked at that point.

TBH, I can't remember the last time I had a 18+. I'm not a high roller, so I don't dabble in that $400+ range where the 18-20 score can be possible. I miss the old days where the KMPs were the standard, and you could easily get a 8+ Looks with 8+ Service for $200. But, BBBJ and other GFE Service was pretty rare. These days, with the cost considerations, I have to be choosy where I find the value, probably playing in the 14 - 17 range with some missteps drifting into the 12-13 range.


Edit: I think the last 19 score I had might've been Nina from Thai Silk. Legitimate 9 Looks, 10 Service for $240. Miss her.
The last 18 I had was probably Abby at New Rainbow. 9 Looks, 9 Service.

Hank.

This makes sense. We need to start rating looks and service saying things like looks 7 service 5

Both numbers matter

I use abcgfe from time to time and have had Looks 10 service 7 and Looks 10 service 0 a bunch of times
 

smatera

All Good.
Messages: 246
Reviews: 7
Joined
#59
This makes sense. We need to start rating looks and service saying things like looks 7 service 5

Both numbers matter

I use abcgfe from time to time and have had Looks 10 service 7 and Looks 10 service 0 a bunch of times
Yes.. let’s numerify these services just like they do movies and other forms of entertainment.
 

cher_cheri

Je ne regrette rien
Messages: 2,020
Reviews: 84
Joined
#60
I have a number system that I use for my own reference, but no one else is likely to understand it, so I don't use it in reviews. I did explain it in this thread: https://www.ampreviews.net/index.php?threads/what-i-have-learned-about-japanese-visitors.143772/
Some reviewers, like @AutomaticSlim do use numerical ratings. I feel that people interpret a 6 or a 9 or a 10 wildly differently, even apart from differences in preferred body type. By my system, which is a five point scale, in the order Body, Face, Skill, Attitude/personality Taylor would be 1254.
 
Top